Nutrition

How to read a dog food label: spotting good food

Ingredient list, “with chicken”, crude ash, animal derivatives: how to read a dog food label and compare dry and wet food fairly.

By the DoggoMeal editorial teamPublished 8 min read

In short

Ingredients are listed in descending order by weight, and “with chicken” only means at least 4% chicken. What matters most is “complete feed” and the analytical constituents – and you can only compare those between dry and wet food on a dry matter basis.

A dog food label tells you more than the front of the pack suggests. Ingredients are listed in descending order by weight, claims like “with chicken” have fixed minimum levels, and you can only compare crude protein or crude fat between dry and wet food fairly once you take the water out of the equation. Here we go through the label line by line.

First of all: a good food doesn’t have to be expensive, and an expensive one isn’t automatically good. According to the WSAVA, marketing terms like “premium” or “holistic” are not regulated and are of little use for judging a food. The important information is in the small print on the back.

Open and closed declaration

There are two permitted ways to list the composition. Either the manufacturer names each ingredient individually, for example “chicken, dried, rice, salmon oil”. Or they group ingredients into categories, such as “meat and animal derivatives, cereals, minerals”. The EU feed regulation explicitly allows pet food to state the category instead of the individual ingredient. The categories themselves come from an older EU directive from 1982.

In everyday use the first option is called “open declaration”, the second “closed declaration”. The law only requires the ingredients to appear under the heading “Composition”, in descending order by weight. Percentages for every ingredient are voluntary for dog food. A percentage only becomes mandatory when the packaging highlights a particular ingredient.

What this means for you: an open declaration isn’t automatically a better food, but you know more precisely what’s inside. According to FEDIAF, categories deliberately give manufacturers flexibility depending on which raw materials are available. So the exact mix can change without the label changing.

Order, first ingredient and meat content

Ingredients are listed by their weight at mixing, heaviest first. That sounds simple, but there’s a catch: fresh meat is weighed with its water. The industry federation FEDIAF works with around 75% water for ingredients of animal origin. If “chicken, fresh (30%)” is at the top, much of it evaporates in dry food, because finished dry food contains only around 10% water according to the Merck Veterinary Manual. A dried ingredient further down the list can end up contributing more protein.

For claims in the name or on the pack, the labelling code of the European industry federation FEDIAF sets fixed minimum levels:

Claim on the packMinimum share of the named ingredient
“beef flavour”0%, the taste comes from the flavouring
“flavoured with beef”more than 0%, but under 4%
“with chicken” / “contains chicken”at least 4%
“rich in chicken” / “extra chicken”at least 14%
“chicken” as variety name / “chicken dinner”at least 26%
“all chicken” / “only chicken”no other ingredients except permitted additives, minerals and water for processing

A figure in brackets, such as “chicken (4%)”, is mandatory as soon as the pack highlights an ingredient. If it says “with chicken and rice”, there must be at least 4% of each, by the way. There is no legal minimum meat content for dog food. The rules only cover how honestly a share has to be named.

Sugar, caramel and flavourings

Sugar appears in the composition under the category “various sugars”, sometimes also as caramel, which is burnt sugar. Dogs don’t need it: according to the Merck Veterinary Manual, carbohydrates are not considered essential nutrients for adult dogs. Too much simple sugar can even have adverse effects in the gut.

For flavourings and colourants, pet food often only needs to state the functional group, i.e. “flavourings” or “colourants”, without the exact substance. Flavourings are meant to improve smell and taste, colourants the colour. They don’t supply any nutrient. A food that does without them isn’t missing anything your dog needs.

Preservatives and natural antioxidants

Fat in food can go rancid. To prevent this, manufacturers add antioxidants. These are often tocopherols, i.e. vitamin E. The Merck Veterinary Manual explicitly names mixed tocopherols as a way to prevent oxidation and rancidity of fat.

On the label, preservatives and antioxidants often only appear as a group, for example “antioxidants” or “preservatives”. That is allowed. The manufacturer must then tell you on request which substance has been added and in what amount. In principle, only authorised additives may be used. One example showing that authorisation isn’t permanent: ethoxyquin has not been authorised as a feed additive in the EU since 2022 (Implementing Regulation (EU) 2022/1375).

So an antioxidant isn’t a warning sign – it protects the food. Whether it comes from a natural source or is synthetic isn’t stated on the pack when only the group is given.

Putting “animal derivatives” in context

“Meat and animal derivatives” is a legally defined category. It covers all the fleshy parts of slaughtered warm-blooded land animals, fresh or preserved, and all products and derivatives from processing their carcases.

That sounds like waste, but it doesn’t have to be. It also includes organ meats such as liver, heart, lungs or tripe, which supply plenty of nutrients and have simply gone out of fashion in the kitchen. In the EU, pet food may be made from so-called Category 3 material. This includes parts of slaughtered animals that would be fit for human consumption but are not sold as food for commercial reasons. According to FEDIAF, all animal material in pet food comes from animals passed as fit for human consumption.

The honest catch: the group term doesn’t tell you which parts are inside and in what amounts. If that matters to you, choose a food that names its animal ingredients individually, or ask the manufacturer.

Complete feed or complementary feed

This line is the most important on the whole pack. Under EU law, a complete feed is sufficient for a daily ration because of its composition. A complementary feed only covers the daily needs together with other feeds. This includes many treats, chews and some wet foods.

The WSAVA advises feeding foods intended for “complementary” or “intermittent” feeding only as a small part of the diet, at most around 10%. Also check whether the complete feed suits your dog’s life stage. For puppies it must be designed for growth. According to the WSAVA, food “for all life stages” is formulated for growth and reproduction.

Analytical constituents and dry matter

Complete feeds for dogs must declare crude protein, crude fat, crude fibre and crude ash. Moisture is mandatory once it exceeds 14%, so in practice on every wet food.

  • Crude protein: the protein content.
  • Crude fat: the fat content.
  • Crude fibre: the fibre fraction.
  • Crude ash: not added, but the residue left after burning the sample in the lab, mainly reflecting minerals.
  • Moisture: the water content.

All values refer to the food as it comes out of the pack. That’s why wet food looks low in protein at first glance. The Merck Veterinary Manual puts it this way: comparisons across different food types should be made on a dry matter or caloric basis. The calculation is simple: 100 minus moisture gives the dry matter, then divide the nutrient value by that figure.

ValueDry foodWet food
Moisture on the label10%78%
Dry matter (100 – moisture)90%22%
Crude protein on the label24%9%
Crude protein in the dry matter24 ÷ 0.90 ≈ 26.7%9 ÷ 0.22 ≈ 40.9%

So the wet food with only 9% on the label has clearly more protein without the water than the dry food with 24%. You can compare crude fat and crude ash with the same calculation. How much protein your dog actually needs is covered in the guide How much protein does a dog need?.

What this means for your dog’s bowl

The label helps you assess a commercial food. Whether the ration in the bowl is well built overall is something you can check with the Food Check: how well is your dog’s bowl put together?

If you’re thinking about feeding fresh food fully or partly, the comparison Dry food, wet food or fresh food explains the differences calmly.

Work it out

If you cook at home, you need a fully calculated ration. Meat and vegetables alone aren’t enough: calcium, a good oil such as salmon, linseed or rapeseed oil, and minerals belong in it. The fresh food calculator gives you the amount for your dog, and you’ll find suitable meals among the recipes.

Calculate now

And one more house rule that applies to every food: salt, sugar, honey and spices have no place in a dog’s bowl, and neither do bones or raw meat.

Work it out

Matching calculators, free in your browser

How well is your dog's bowl put together overall? Free Food Check

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

What does open declaration mean on dog food?

In everyday use it means every ingredient is listed by its own name, often with a percentage. A closed declaration only uses group terms such as “meat and animal derivatives” or “cereals”. Both are allowed under EU law. Percentages are only mandatory for ingredients the packaging specifically highlights.

What are animal derivatives in dog food?

Legally it is a category: all the fleshy parts of slaughtered warm-blooded land animals and all products from processing their carcases. This includes liver, heart or tripe, which can be valuable. According to the industry federation, the material comes from animals passed as fit for human consumption. The group term doesn’t tell you exactly which parts are inside, though.

How do I recognise a good dry dog food?

First check for “complete feed” and the right life stage. Then look for an ingredient list that names specific ingredients rather than only categories, and for a way to contact the manufacturer. Terms like “premium” or “holistic” are not regulated and say little about quality.

What does crude ash mean in dog food?

Crude ash is not added ash. It is the residue left in the lab after a sample is burnt, and mainly reflects the mineral content, such as calcium and phosphorus. It must be declared on complete feeds for dogs.

How much meat should be in dog food?

EU feed law sets no legal minimum meat content. What is set out is how proportions are labelled: under the labelling code of the industry federation FEDIAF, “with chicken” means at least 4%, “rich in chicken” at least 14%, “chicken dinner” at least 26%. More important than a meat figure is that the food supplies all nutrients as a complete feed.

How do I compare dry and wet dog food?

On a dry matter basis: 100 minus moisture gives the dry matter, then divide the nutrient value by that share. A wet food with 9% crude protein and 78% moisture has about 41% protein in the dry matter, a dry food with 24% crude protein and 10% moisture about 27%.

References

Sources

This article is based on the following expert sources. You can read how we work under Editorial team & methodology.

  1. Verordnung (EG) Nr. 767/2009 über das Inverkehrbringen und die Verwendung von Futtermitteln (konsolidierte Fassung) – EUR-Lex
  2. Richtlinie 82/475/EWG über die Kategorien von Ausgangserzeugnissen für die Kennzeichnung von Mischfuttermitteln für Heimtiere – EUR-Lex
  3. Verordnung (EG) Nr. 1069/2009 über tierische Nebenprodukte – EUR-Lex
  4. Durchführungsverordnung (EU) 2022/1375 zur Verweigerung der Zulassung von Ethoxyquin – EUR-Lex
  5. Code of Good Labelling Practice for Pet Food (2019) – FEDIAF – European Pet Food Industry Federation
  6. Dog and Cat Foods – Merck Veterinary Manual
  7. Nutritional Requirements of Small Animals – Merck Veterinary Manual
  8. Guidelines on Selecting Pet Foods – WSAVA Global Nutrition Committee
DoggoMeal app

Less maths, more cooking.

The article tells you what matters. The DoggoMeal app turns it into a recipe with gram amounts to suit your dog's weight, age, activity and allergies.

  • Dog profile
  • Recipes with gram amounts
  • Allergy warnings
  • Doggopedia

Free · no subscription · every feature included

DoggoMeal app: recipe with gram amounts per day and per portion
DoggoMeal logo with a sitting Shiba
About the editorial team

DoggoMeal editorial team

DoggoMeal is a dog nutrition app, founded and run by Kim Marques. Nami, our Shiba, is part of everyday life – her experiences with food changes, bland diets and the like appear in many articles as personal examples.

Our content follows the recommendations of the NRC, WSAVA and FEDIAF. You'll find the sources for this article above under “Sources”. The articles are no substitute for veterinary advice – if your dog has symptoms, please talk to your vet.

More from the magazine

Keep reading

Related articles from the DoggoMeal Magazine – or all articles on “Nutrition”.